This Article Abstract Free Full Text (Free PDF) Free Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Alert me to new issues of the journal Add to Saved Citations Download to citation manager Request Permissions Request Reprints Add to My Marked Citations Citing Articles Citing Articles via Google Scholar Citing Articles via Scopus Google Scholar Articles by Hill, L. Search for Related Content Social Bookmarking                         What's this?

Adam Smith, Adam Ferguson and Karl Marx on the Division of Labour

University of Adelaide, Australia, lisa.hill{at}adelaide.edu.au

Adam Smith (1723—90) and Adam Ferguson (1723—1816) shared a keen interest in the social, economic and individual effects of specialization. Though this mutual interest led to a protracted priority dispute between them, nevertheless their approaches differed significantly. Ferguson was generally more negative in his attitude and was also less interested in the economic effects of specialization, focusing instead on its adverse social ramifications. In fact, his work on the subject probably constitutes the first fully developed sociological account of the topic. Karl Marx quoted Ferguson approvingly and declared that he had been inspired by the latter's insights. But Smith too made some extremely negative and apparently pessimistic observations about the division of labour, giving rise to suggestions that his comments also `constitute a major source of inspiration for the socialist critique' of commercialism. This article compares and contrasts the respective approaches of the two Scots. It also pays particular attention to claims that there are parallels with Marx in their thinking. To what extent is this true? Further, if it is true, do they anticipate him in the same way?

Key Words: alienation • division of labour • Durkheim • Ferguson • inequality • Smith • Spencer • Marx • work

References

• Altick, Richard (1983) The English Common Reader: A Social History of the Mass Reading Public 1800—1900, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
• Barry, Norman (1982) `The Tradition of Spontaneous Order', Literature of Liberty 5(2): 7—58.
• Brewer, John D. (1986) `Adam Ferguson and the Theme of Exploitation', The British Journal of Sociology 37: 461—78.[CrossRef]
• Brewer, John D. (1987) `The Scottish Enlightenment', pp. 6—28 in Andrew Reeve (ed.) Modern Theories of Exploitation. London: Sage.
• Brewer, John D. (1989) `Conjectural History, Sociology and Social Change in Eighteenth-Century Scotland: Adam Ferguson and the Division of Labour', pp. 13—30 in David McCrone, Stephen Kendrick and Pat Straw (eds) The Making of Scotland: Nation, Culture and Social Change. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press in conjunction with The British Sociological Association.
• Campbell, W.F. (1966) `Adam Smith's Theory of Justice, Prudence and Beneficence ', American Economic Review LVII(2): 571—7.
• Carlyle, Alexander (1910) The Autobiography of Dr Alexander Carlyle of Inveresk, 1722—1805, ed. John Hill Burton. London and Edinburgh: T.N. Foulis.
• Drosos, Dionysios (1996) `Adam Smith and Karl Marx: Alienation in Market Society', History of Economic Ideas IV (1—2): 325—51.
• Durkheim, Émile (1984) The Division of Labour in Society, ed. Lewis Coser, trans. W.D. Halls. Basingstoke: Macmillan. (Orig. pub. 1983.)
• Ferguson, Adam (1756) Reflections Previous to the Establishment of a Militia. London: R and J. Dodsley.
• Ferguson, Adam (1792) Principles of Moral and Political Science: Being Chiefly a Retrospect of Lectures Delivered in the College of Edinburgh, in Two Volumes, Edinburgh: Printed for A. Strahan and T. Cadell. London; and W. Creech, Edinburgh.
• Ferguson, Adam (1834) The History of the Progress and Termination of the Roman Republic. London: Jones and Company. (Orig. pub. 1783.)
• Ferguson, Adam (1978) Institutes of Moral Philosophy. New York: Garland. (Orig. pub. 1769.)
• Ferguson, Adam (1995) The Correspondence of Adam Ferguson, 3 vols, ed. V. Merolle with an introduction by J.B. Fagg. London: William Pickering.
• Ferguson, Adam (1996a) An Essay on the History of Civil Society, ed. and with an introduction by Fania Oz-Salzberger. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (Orig. pub. 1767.)
• Ferguson, Adam (1996b) Collection of Essays, ed. and with an introduction by Yasuo Amoh. Kyoto: Rinsen.
• Ferrarotti, Franco (1984) `Civil Society and State Structures in Creative Tension', State, Culture and Society 1(Fall): 3—25.
• Fiori, Stefano and Enzo Pesciarelli (1999) `Adam Smith on Relations of Subordination, Personal Incentives and the Division of Labour', Scottish Journal of Political Economy 46(1): 91—106.[CrossRef]
• Foley, Vernon (1974) `The Division of Labour in Plato and Smith', History of Political Economy 6(2): 221—2.
• Forbes, Duncan (1967a) Edinburgh in the Age of Reason. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
• Forbes, Duncan (1967b) `Introduction', pp. xiii—xlii in Adam Ferguson, An Essay on the History of Civil Society, ed. and with an introduction by Duncan Forbes. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
• Gay, Peter (1970) The Enlightenment: An Interpretation, 2 vols. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
• Griswold, Charles (1999) The Virtues of the Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Groenewegan, Peter (1977) `Adam Smith and the Division of Labour: A Bicentenary Estimate', Australian Economic Papers 16(29): 161—74.[CrossRef]
• Hamowy, Ronald (1968) `Adam Smith, Adam Ferguson and the Division of Labour', Economica 35(139): 244—59.
• Hamowy, Ronald (1986) `Progress and Commerce in Anglo-American Thought: The Social Philosophy of Adam Ferguson', Interpretation 4(Jan.): 61—87.
• Heilbroner, Robert L. (1973) `The Paradox of Progress: Decline and Decay in the Wealth of Nations', Journal of the History of Ideas 34: 243—62.[CrossRef]
• Hill, Lisa (1996) `Anticipations of Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Social Thought in the Work of Adam Ferguson', European Journal of Sociology 37(1): 203—28.
• Hill, Lisa (1997) `Adam Ferguson and the Paradox of Progress and Decline', History of Political Thought 18(4): 677—706.
• Hill, Lisa (1998) `The Invisible Hand of Adam Ferguson', The European Legacy 3(6): 42—65.
• Hill, Lisa (2001) `The Hidden Theology of Adam Smith', European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 8(1): 1—29.[CrossRef]
• Hill, Lisa (2004) `Further Reflections on the Hidden Theology of Adam Smith', European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 11(4): 629—35.[CrossRef]
• Hill, Lisa (2006) The Passionate Society: The Social, Political and Moral Thought of Adam Ferguson. Dordrecht: Springer.
• Hont, Istvan (1983) `The "Rich Country, Poor Country" Debate in Scottish Classical Political Economy', pp. 271—315 in Istvan Hont and Michael Ignatieff (eds) Wealth and Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Hont, Istvan and Michael Ignatieff (eds) (1983) Wealth and Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Hosseini, Hamid (1998) `Seeking the Roots of Adam Smith's Division of Labour in Medieval Persia', History of Political Economy 30(4): 653—81.[Free Full Text]
• Hume, David (1932) Letters of David Hume, 2 vols, ed. J.Y.T. Greig. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
• Kemper, Theodore, D. (1975). `Émile Durkheim and the Division of Labour', The Sociological Quarterly 16(2): 190—206.[CrossRef]
• Kettler, David (1965) The Social and Political Thought of Adam Ferguson. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.
• Kindleberger, Charles (1976) `The Historical Background: Adam Smith and the Industrial Revolution', pp. 93—104, in Thomas Wilson and Andrew S. Skinner (eds) The Market and the State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Lamb, Robert (1973) `Adam Smith's Concept of Alienation', Oxford Economic Papers 25(2): 275—85.[Free Full Text]
• Lavezzi, Andrea (2003) `Smith, Marshall and Young on Division of Labour and Economic Growth', European History of Economic Thought 10(1): 81—108.[CrossRef]
• Lehmann, William C. (1930) Adam Ferguson and the Beginnings of Modern Sociology. New York: Columbia University Press.
• Lehmann, William C. (1974) `Review of Salvucci's Adam Ferguson: Sociologicae Filosofia Politica', History and Society 13(2):163—81.
• Loasby, Brian J. (1996) `The Division of Labour', History of Economic Ideas IV(1—2): 299—323.
• McNulty, Paul. J. (1975) `A Note on the Division of Labour in Plato and Smith', History of Political Economy 7(3): 372—89.[Free Full Text]
• Marx, Karl (1969) The Poverty of Philosophy, with an introduction by Frederick Engels, International Publishers: New York. (Orig. pub. 1847.)
• Marx, Karl (1977) Capital, 3 vols. Moscow: Progress. (Orig. pub. 1867—94.)
• Marx, Karl and Friedrich Engels (1978) The Marx—Engels Reader, ed. Robert. C. Tucker. New York: Norton.
• Meek, Ronald (1967) `The Scottish Contribution to Marxist Sociology ', pp. 34—45 in Economics, Ideology and Other Essays. London: Chapman & Hall.
• Meek, Ronald L. and Andrew S. Skinner (1973) `The Development of Adam Smith's Ideas on the Division of Labour', Economic Journal 83(332): 1094—116.[CrossRef]
• Merton, Robert K. (1934) `Durkheim's Division of Labour in Society', The American Journal of Sociology 40(3): 319—28.[CrossRef]
• Millar, John (1803) An Historical View of the English Government from the Settlement of the Saxons in Britain to the Accession of the House of Stuart, 4 vols. Glasgow: T.N. Foulis.
• Mizuta, Hiroshi (1981) `Two Adams in the Scottish Enlightenment', Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century 191: 812—19.
• Myers, Milton (1967) `The Division of Labour as a Principle of Social Cohesion', Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 33(3): 432—40.[CrossRef]
• Pack, Spencer J. (1991) Capitalism as a Moral System: Adam Smith's Critique of the Free Market Economy. Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
• Pascal, Roy (1938) `Property and Society: The Scottish Historical School of the Eighteenth Century', Modern Quarterly 1: 167—79.
• Perrin, Robert (1995) `Émile Durkheim's Division of Labour and the Shadow of Herbert Spencer', The Sociological Quarterly 36(4): 791—808.[CrossRef]
• Phillipson, Nicholas (1983) `Adam Smith as Civic Moralist', pp. 179—202 in Istvan Hont and Michael Ignatieff (eds) Wealth and Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Rae, John (1965) Life of Adam Smith. London: Macmillan. Reproduction, New York: Augustus M.Kelley. (Orig. pub. 1895.)
• Rashid, Salim (1986) `Adam Smith and the Division of Labour: A Historical View', Scottish Journal of Political Economy 33(3): 292—7.[CrossRef]
• Ricoy, Carlos J. (2003) `Marx on Division of Labour, Mechanization and Technical Progress', European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 10(1): 47—79.[CrossRef]
• Robertson, John (1985) The Scottish Enlightenment and the Militia Issue. Edinburgh: John Donald.
• Robertson, John (2000) `The Scottish Contribution to the Enlightenment', pp. 37—62 in Paul Wood (ed.) The Scottish Enlightenment: Essays in Reinterpretation. Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press.
• Rosenberg, Nathan (1965) `Adam Smith on the Division of Labour: Two Views or One', Economica, Feb.: 127—39.
• Sher, Richard B. (1989) `Adam Ferguson, Adam Smith, and the Problem of National Defense', Journal of Modern History 61(2): 240—68.[CrossRef]
• Skinner, Andrew (1995) `Pufendorf, Hutcheson and Adam Smith: Some Principles of Political Economy', Scottish Journal of Political Economy 42(2): 165—82.[CrossRef]
• Smith, Adam (1976) The Theory of Moral Sentiments, ed. D.D. Raphael and A.L. MacFie. Oxford: Clarendon Press. (Orig. pub. 1759.)
• Smith, Adam (1978a) Lectures on Jurisprudence (A and B), ed. R.L. Meek, D.D. Raphael and L.G. Stein. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Smith, Adam (1978b) `Early Draft of the Wealth of Nations', pp. 561—86 in Adam Smith, Lectures on Jurisprudence (A and B), ed. R.L. Meek, D.D. Raphael and L.G. Stein. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Smith, Adam (1979) An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, ed. R.H. Campbell and A.S. Skinner. Oxford: Clarendon Press. (Orig. pub. 1776.)
• Smith, Adam (1980) `The History of Astronomy', Essays on Philosophical Subjects, ed. I.S. Ross. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
• Smith, Adam (1987) The Correspondence of Adam Smith, ed. E.C. Mossner and I.S. Ross. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Spencer, Herbert. (1892) Essays: Scientific, Political and Speculative, 3 vols. London and New York: Elibron Classics.
• Stewart, Dugald (1980) `Account of the Life and Writings of Adam Smith, LLD', ed. I.S.Ross, pp. 256—332 in Adam Smith, Essays on Philosophical Subjects, ed. W.P.D.Wightman and J.C.Bryce. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Swingewood, Alan (1984) A Short History of Sociological Thought. London: Macmillan.
• Waszek, Norbert (1983) `The Division of Labour from the Scottish Enlightenment to Hegel', The Owl of Minerva: Quarterly Journal of the Hegel Society of America 15(1): 51—75.
• West, Edwin G. (1964) `Adam Smith's Two Views on the Division of Labour ', Economica 31(121): 23—32.[CrossRef]
• West, Edwin G. (1969) `The Political Economy of Alienation: Karl Marx and Adam Smith', Oxford Economic Papers 21(1): 1—23.[Free Full Text]
• West, Edwin. G. (1996) `Adam Smith on the Cultural Effects of Specialisation: Splenetics versus Economics', History of Political Economy 28(1): 83—105.[Free Full Text]
• Winch, Donald (1978) Adam Smith's Politics: An Essay in Historiographic Revision. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Journal of Classical Sociology, Vol. 7, No. 3, 339-366 (2007)
DOI: 10.1177/1468795X07082086


CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    Twitter    What's this?

This Article Abstract Free Full Text (Free PDF) Free Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Alert me to new issues of the journal Add to Saved Citations Download to citation manager Request Permissions Request Reprints Add to My Marked Citations Citing Articles Citing Articles via Google Scholar Citing Articles via Scopus Google Scholar Articles by Hill, L. Search for Related Content Social Bookmarking                         What's this?